At some point in almost every serious New York workers' compensation case, the question comes up: should I settle? In New York, settling a workers' comp claim usually means signing a Section 32 agreement — a one-time deal that closes your case in exchange for a payment. It can be the right move or a costly mistake, and the difference often comes down to understanding how the number is built and what you're giving up.
This guide explains what a Section 32 settlement is, how settlements are valued, the Workers' Compensation Board approval process, the choice between a lump sum and a structured payout, and how your Average Weekly Wage (AWW) and any Schedule Loss of Use (SLU) award drive the final figure.
What Is a Section 32 Settlement?
"Section 32" refers to Section 32 of the New York Workers' Compensation Law, which allows an injured worker and the insurance carrier to voluntarily agree to resolve a claim. Instead of leaving the case open and collecting weekly checks and medical coverage indefinitely, both sides agree on a sum that closes the case — in whole or in part.
A Section 32 settlement can cover:
- Indemnity (lost-wage) benefits — the weekly checks you receive for your disability.
- Future medical benefits — the carrier's obligation to pay for treatment related to your injury. You can settle indemnity only and keep medical open, or close both.
- The entire claim — most full Section 32 agreements close both indemnity and medical, ending the carrier's obligations for good.
How Workers' Comp Settlements Are Valued
There is no fixed formula for a New York workers' comp settlement. Two workers with the same injury can settle for very different amounts depending on their wages, age, and how strong each side's case is. That said, almost every Section 32 number is built from the same set of building blocks:
1. The value of your future indemnity benefits
This is usually the largest piece. The carrier estimates how many more weeks it would likely have to pay you, at what weekly rate, if the case stayed open. That depends directly on your Average Weekly Wage and your degree of disability. A higher weekly benefit and a longer expected period of payments both push the settlement value up.
2. The value of any permanency award
If your injury qualifies for a Schedule Loss of Use (SLU) award (for arms, legs, hands, feet, fingers, eyes, ears, etc.) or a Loss of Wage Earning Capacity (LWEC) classification (for the back, neck, and other non-schedule injuries), that award is a major anchor for the settlement. An SLU award has a defined dollar value; an LWEC classification translates into a stream of weekly payments — both feed directly into the negotiation.
3. Projected future medical costs
If you're settling medical benefits too, the carrier estimates what your future care — doctor visits, physical therapy, prescriptions, possible surgery, durable medical equipment — would cost over your lifetime. The more ongoing treatment your injury requires, the more this piece is worth.
4. Your age and life expectancy
A younger worker with a permanent disability has more years of potential benefits ahead, which generally increases settlement value. Age is a key variable on both the indemnity and medical sides.
5. The strength of the disputed issues
Settlement is a compromise of risk. If the carrier has a real chance of winning — disputing whether your injury is work-related, your degree of disability, or your wage rate — that uncertainty lowers the number, because you're trading the risk of getting nothing for the certainty of getting something. A clean, well-documented, established claim settles for more than a hotly contested one.
6. A discount to present value
Finally, because you receive the money now instead of spread out over years, the projected future value is discounted to a present-day lump sum. This is why a settlement is almost always less than the raw total of every benefit you could theoretically collect over a lifetime.
What raises and lowers your number
- Raises it: a high AWW, a strong SLU or LWEC percentage, a young age, heavy future medical needs, and a well-established, undisputed claim.
- Lowers it: a low AWW, weak or contested permanency evidence, older age, minimal future treatment, and serious disputes the carrier might win.
The Role of AWW and SLU in the Number
Two numbers do more to shape a New York settlement than any others: your Average Weekly Wage and your Schedule Loss of Use award. They're worth understanding on their own.
Average Weekly Wage (AWW)
Your AWW is the foundation of every dollar figure in your case. It's based on your earnings in the year before your injury (including overtime and, in some cases, a second job), and it sets your weekly benefit rate — generally two-thirds of your AWW, multiplied by your percentage of disability, up to the state maximum for your date of accident. Because the settlement starts from the value of those weekly checks, an AWW that's set too low quietly shrinks everything that follows. Confirming your AWW is correct is one of the highest-leverage things you can do before settling. Our guide to Average Weekly Wage walks through how it's calculated.
Schedule Loss of Use (SLU)
For injuries to an extremity — arm, leg, hand, foot, finger, toe, eye, or ear — New York pays a Schedule Loss of Use award based on a fixed number of weeks for that body part, multiplied by your percentage of permanent loss and your weekly benefit rate. Because an SLU award already produces a concrete dollar figure, it often becomes the backbone of the settlement: the parties argue over the loss-of-use percentage, attach a number to it, and build the Section 32 around that. Our SLU guide explains which body parts qualify and how the percentage is determined.
Lump Sum vs. Structured Settlement
Once you've agreed on an amount, there's a second decision: how you receive it. A Section 32 can be paid as a lump sum or as a structured settlement.
Lump sum
A lump sum pays the entire net amount at once. The advantages are control and flexibility — you can pay off debt, cover immediate needs, or invest as you see fit. The risk is that a large one-time payment can be spent quickly or mismanaged, and once it's gone, the case is closed and there are no more checks coming.
Structured settlement
A structured settlement pays the amount out over time — monthly, annually, or in scheduled future installments — typically funded through an annuity purchased by the carrier. The advantages are guaranteed long-term income and protection against spending it all at once. A structure can also help preserve eligibility for needs-based benefits like Medicaid or SSI, where a large lump sum could otherwise push you over an asset limit.
Which one fits you?
- Lean lump sum if you have immediate financial needs, you're comfortable managing a large sum, or you want maximum flexibility.
- Lean structured if you want guaranteed income over time, you're worried about spending it too fast, or you receive (or may need) needs-based government benefits.
- Watch for Medicare: if you're a Medicare beneficiary or likely to become one, the settlement may need a Medicare Set-Aside to protect future medical coverage. This is an area where professional guidance matters.
The Board Approval Process
A Section 32 agreement is not a private contract you can simply sign — the Workers' Compensation Board must approve it before it takes effect. This is a built-in protection to make sure injured workers understand what they're signing and aren't being shortchanged.
Step 1: The agreement is submitted
The parties put the settlement terms in writing on the Board's Section 32 forms, including a stipulation describing exactly what's being settled (indemnity, medical, or both) and the amount. The package is submitted to the Board.
Step 2: The Board schedules a hearing (in most cases)
When a hearing is held, a Workers' Compensation Law Judge (WCLJ) reviews the agreement there. If you're represented, your attorney appears with you; if you're unrepresented, the judge takes extra care to explain the terms. The judge confirms on the record that you understand you are permanently closing your case and giving up future benefits. A hearing is not always held: the Board can review an agreement without one when all parties (other than minors and unrepresented claimants) request desk review, or when the agreement settles indemnity benefits only. Agreements can be approved administratively by the Chair, a designee of the Chair, a member of the Board, or a WCLJ, based on a review of the record.
Step 3: The judge checks that it's fair
The judge will not approve an agreement that is unfair or unconscionable. The Board looks at whether the amount is reasonable given the injury, your wage rate, your age, and the issues in the case. If the settlement looks far too low, the judge can decline to approve it.
Step 4: The 10-day window and approval
The 10-day period runs from the date the agreement is deemed submitted to the Board, not from the date it is approved. When a hearing is held, the agreement is deemed submitted at the hearing; when it is reviewed without a hearing, the Board tells the parties in writing the date it is deemed submitted. During those 10 calendar days, any party can withdraw from the agreement. A withdrawal must be in writing and received by the Board within the 10 days. After that, the Board can approve the agreement, and once approved, the Section 32 is binding and final. The insurer is required to pay the award within 10 days after the decision approving the settlement is filed by the Board.
Should You Settle? Questions to Ask First
Settling can bring closure and a meaningful payment, but it's permanent. Before you agree to a Section 32, work through these questions:
Before you sign a Section 32
- Is my Average Weekly Wage correct? If it's too low, every figure built on it is too low.
- Has my permanency (SLU percentage or LWEC classification) been properly evaluated, or am I settling before I know what it's worth?
- Am I closing medical benefits too — and if so, can I afford future treatment out of pocket or through the settlement?
- Have I reached maximum medical improvement, or might I still need more treatment that could raise my case value?
- Do I receive (or might I need) Medicaid, SSI, or Medicare? A lump sum can affect those benefits.
- Would a structured payout protect me better than a lump sum?
- Have I had the offer reviewed by someone who works in New York comp every day?
Should You Have an Attorney?
You can negotiate a Section 32 on your own, but carriers settle cases for a living and you generally settle one once. An experienced New York workers' compensation attorney can press for the correct AWW, fight for a higher permanency percentage, structure the deal to protect government benefits, and recognize when an offer is below what the case is worth.
If you'd like to be matched with a workers' compensation attorney in your area, you can connect with an attorney through The Comp Desk.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Section 32 settlement?
A voluntary, binding agreement under Workers' Compensation Law § 32 in which you and the insurance carrier agree to close all or part of your claim for a set payment. Either side can withdraw in writing within 10 calendar days of the date it is deemed submitted to the Board (the hearing date, when there is a hearing); once the Board approves it after that, it's almost always final.
How is a workers' comp settlement amount calculated in New York?
There's no fixed formula. The number is built from the value of your future weekly benefits (driven by your AWW), any SLU or LWEC permanency award, projected future medical costs, your age, the strength of the disputed issues, and a discount to present-day value.
Can I reopen my case after a Section 32 settlement?
Generally no. A Section 32 is designed to be final. Once approved and binding, you usually cannot reopen the claim even if your condition worsens — which is why the decision deserves careful thought before you sign.
How long does it take to get paid?
For 10 calendar days from the date the agreement is deemed submitted to the Board (the hearing date, when there is a hearing), either side can withdraw in writing. After that, the Board can approve it; once approved, the settlement is binding, and the insurer is required to pay within 10 days after the decision approving the settlement is filed by the Board.
Lump sum or structured — which is better?
It depends on your situation. A lump sum gives flexibility and control; a structure gives guaranteed income over time and can protect needs-based benefits like Medicaid or SSI. If you receive government benefits or worry about spending it too fast, a structure is worth considering.
Estimate Your Settlement Before You Negotiate
The Comp Desk's free Settlement Calculator helps you ballpark what your New York workers' comp case may be worth — so you can recognize a fair Section 32 offer instead of guessing.
Try the Settlement Calculator →